martes, 18 de noviembre de 2014

Experiences. Elections.

Yesterday the presidential elections took place. And as always happens, words based on conjectures and speculations of all kinds prevailed—at least that is what I perceive—a single discourse: the discourse that everyone is wrong and everyone is right, alongside a multitude of small independent discourses in which everyone holds their own truth, together forming that single discourse. The truth is that, with the elections over, I can draw many conclusions that naturally do not escape this single discourse formed by all these mini-discourses, and which differ in no way from any of them. My conclusions are the truth; they are my truth, whether anyone likes it or not.

Finally, the candidate I voted for for the presidency ended up in third place, just as the polls predicted. The topic of the polls is interesting, though not much different from the rest. They tend to make front-page news after an election when they get it wrong due to a surprise turnout from the electorate; however, this almost never happens, which is why it is the exception. Exit polls usually show the final outcome. This election was no different: the ruling-party candidate won, failing to surpass 45 percent of the vote, and held a 20-point lead over the runner-up, who also happened to be a woman. The polls hinted at a potential runoff, but I believe that was just momentum aimed at reaching one rather than something grounded in real data. Once the voting ended, television was already displaying figures that later materialized with only minor differences.

Who encouraged that momentum I speak of? It is very difficult to answer: the media in the first place, and here is where interests come into play. The parties involved? Was it the ruling party itself promoting and/or choosing its rival? The rival, based on their own measurements, seeking a position and building on what real ground they had? The interests of certain powerful groups trying to maintain their power or seeking that space of power? The pollsters—whom do they answer to? Do they favor those who pay for their work? Do they act independently, delivering quality? We do not know; both scenarios are conceivable.

Now, let us get into the comments and speeches following the election. This is where all sorts of things begin to blossom. I will try to make this as broad as possible—at least covering everything I can recall. Let us not forget that each and every one of them is right, possesses the truth, and together they form the truth. I will try to always start with the negative, solely for the purpose of drawing something good out of it, because what is negative is what needs to be improved—it is the "ought to be," it is what we aim for. Someone must care; I refuse to believe that no one wants to fix what is wrong, or that people act purely from an individualistic perspective to benefit themselves rather than the whole, when in fact, to benefit oneself, one should benefit the collective.

Let us start before the polls opened. Just one day prior, the designated election board authorities had confirmed only 20% of the total envelopes sent out. Bad and true, the lack of organization was beginning to show, as I will discuss later, and that is wrong. Was it done on purpose? We will never know. I believe that the bureaucracy of the National and Provincial Governments was the primary factor influencing this apparent disorganization. Points to consider include errors in the electoral rolls, along with shortages and delays in issuing ID cards (DNI). As usually happens with ID deliveries, everything is rushed at the last minute, and this was no exception to the rule of experience. As Napoleon once said, "Dress me slowly, for I am in a hurry." Clearly, trying to do on the last day what was not done all year was logically going to turn out badly, as it did. In one case, the Registry staff decided to go on strike for "decent wages"—haha, what more is there to say? It is bureaucracy and apathy from the governments in turn.

Another point to consider is the poll watchers and the citizens. The latter deserve a special paragraph for two reasons I will now explain, one of which involves collusion between the government and the citizen. First, regarding the poll watchers: the more, the better, in my view. However, there was a noticeable absence of poll watchers from opposition parties or those with fewer members. The issue of party membership is a peculiar case due to the lack of oversight and accurate data; nevertheless, minor political parties must guarantee the election one way or another using whatever tools are at hand, one of which is monitoring the voting process itself. Therefore, I believe it is advisable that in every election minor political parties address this issue, even if it means providing training (however minimal, as watching a poll does not require much). It is essential to motivate potential poll watchers so they carry out their duties with enthusiasm.

For this—returning to the point regarding citizens and the government—motivation is needed, preferably in a tangible, positive form. The reality is that citizens do not want to serve as poll watchers; they go under compulsion because it is a public obligation. There is always a mix: some are volunteers, while others must attend due to their roles (teachers, judicial officials). But facts reveal that the average person tries to avoid an activity that consumes an entire workday when it could be a day of rest. When "we fought" for the right to vote, having gone through the sad experience of being unable to vote, now that we can—during our longest uninterrupted period of exercising it—why not strengthen it? This is precisely when we should strengthen the institution rather than devalue and neglect it. Citizens should be motivated to find a way to make it something positive rather than negative, as it is currently viewed. 

Political parties should encourage participation beyond campaign propaganda and getting out the vote (a topic that touches on "voluntary voting," an idea I agree with), while the government should provide motivation and training—motivation above all. Currently, a total of $60 (around US$ 3) is paid to the head of the polling station. Each station has at least a head official, an alternate official (both election board authorities), and then the poll watchers. At my station, there were three, with the number varying between three and four across stations. Well, those $60 were split among the five or six people at the table. The math is simple: 10 pesos for sitting all day attending to voters, plus the count and any issues that might arise. That is bad—if you are going to encourage people with financial compensation, let it be real compensation, not a mockery.

Now that the country is emerging from the crisis, with an economic recovery, full coffers, and a surplus, money is not lacking. I know nothing about economics, but you do not need to be sharp to do simple math: pay more—no matter how much, $60, $100, or $150 pesos to each person at the table, rather than a total sum to one person or split among everyone—so that money enters the system. This could then be offset (in case it affects inflation) by the State selling foreign currency. There is a clear lack of interest from the State in motivating the people working at nearly 80,000 polling stations.

Moving on to election day itself: the usual issues occurred—heat strokes among the crowd, lack of space, disorganization, those arriving at the last minute, and those arriving first who were forced to stay at the station due to the absence of required officials. There were occasional troublemakers escorted away and a few misunderstandings, but overall, everything proceeded normally. There were no acts of violence; the media would have covered them instantly, as blood is what sells most. Fortunately, there was none. On this point, the Minister of the Interior was right when he stated that everything proceeded with total normality. It is understandable that he exaggerated a bit afterward, but that is natural given his role; it is logical for him to defend and highlight it, because he must (strictly speaking, it should be "ought to") answer for any problem. A judge later confirmed that "no electoral crimes were recorded," except for three minor infractions.

Then there were the usual irregularities that show the worst of the country and the worst of human nature—both from those who act wrongfully and those who fail to act when they should. Cases were reported of people renting babies to cut ahead in line; in rural provinces, there was manipulation of indigenous communities, taking advantage of their lack of civic awareness and making fun of their names; fake and duplicate IDs; and dead people voting. 

Unbelievable as it sounds, deceased individuals vote due to bureaucracy and administrative negligence—there are significant numbers of deceased citizens still registered on the voting rolls. These are all news items one reads in the media that have become so common they pass almost unnoticed, along with damaged ballots, stolen ballots, etc.

Voting was scheduled to end at six in the evening, but due to irregularities, the hours were extended. In the Capital, it was stretched to seven in the evening—one hour more—while in the Province of Buenos Aires, it was extended until the last person in line had voted. Long queues formed because many voters show up at the last minute—a mark against the citizens. Even though I voted at noon, there were long lines and frustrating waits; in my case, as well as several others with whom I had the chance to talk (no fewer than eight or nine people), it took around an hour and a half.

Once the day concluded, complaints from candidates and their spokespeople began to surface. Among the main contenders—those with the most airtime on television, all of whom lost the election—almost a majority (though not all) focused their primary accusations on a shortage of ballots. This occurred mainly in a section of the suburban area (conurbano), one of the regions with the highest voter density and an economically struggling area (to put it mildly). It seemed almost everyone agreed that, for some reason, the Government or someone benefiting the Government had managed to prevent ballots from reaching their destination at the polling places. The second major accusation was that once the ballots arrived, they systematically vanished or were looted. It was stated publicly, and later shown in the media, that formal complaints were filed by the legal representatives of various political groups.
The initial reports to the media were made hastily. Consequently, within minutes, the Minister of the Interior appeared on air to defend the process and counter the accusations, arguing that it was the political parties' own negligence for failing to send out the ballots as required, as they apparently had not done what they were supposed to do. Regardless, this election left a bad impression on me. Earlier, the media spoke of the Government's refusal to allow international observers. The absence of electronic voting—at least in major urban centers, which are numerous—allows these accusations, whether founded or unfounded, to proliferate. Electronic voting should already be implemented to avoid suspicion.

Tempers flared, leading the runner-up candidate to accuse the President and his wife (the election winner) of celebrating prematurely as a tactic to buy time while counting votes that excluded major urban centers. This accusation eventually faded since the declared results held true, but it remains an interesting dynamic: on one hand, the celebration was premature compared to past elections; on the other hand, it is true that the initial numbers excluded major urban centers, and yet the predicted result came to pass. Could everyone have been right? Perhaps. In my personal opinion, the President had data confirming his victory; otherwise, he would not have taken that risk, especially given how cautious they tend to be. While some losers alleged fraud, others countered that "since time immemorial, the loser always claims fraud."

In the end, the losers acknowledged the winners, and the winners celebrated. What remains beyond doubt is that general disorganization was the true winner.


(originally published on 10/29/2007)

No hay comentarios.:

Publicar un comentario