One of the courses turned out to have a unique characteristic: they wanted us to do a sort of fieldwork. This assignment was reflected in the submission of a term paper. Although it wasn't a course with strict professors, you still had to turn in the assignments, and as always happens, some did it with enthusiasm and others without—the usual. What you did have to do was put in the effort required for what could be called fieldwork, because it required being in contact with what you were studying, stepping out of the classroom, and bringing the abstract study down to reality. Despite this—from which one should learn and draw a lesson—I think many in the class found it extremely difficult to open their minds to the entry of knowledge. But that’s a minor point, because the purpose of this blog post was and is different.
We were looking at the topic of prejudice and the complicated situation of certain groups regarding sexual identity, and one of the fieldwork assignments consisted of attending a film festival (http://www.diversa.com.ar/2007/index_es.htm) that was, of course, centered on the theme. We had to choose a movie and complete a questionnaire they had previously handed out, which was tied to the reading chapters in the book. It didn't seem out of the ordinary at all—nor was it, really—except for the usual narrow-minded people. Basically, the shallow ones, or those who, despite studying prejudice, didn't quite grasp it or refused to let it go. So, under their breath, you could hear these vulgar groups saying, "We're not going to a fag festival," or similar things. That was their first unjustifiable objection, yet it was the first thing that came to mind for these people, who happened to be classmates. Of course, most of them ended up going anyway.
The second point was going in groups, as students. But let's see: if it was an international gay, lesbian, and trans film festival, how could a couple of young student classmates—or a pair of female friends from class—pass as regular moviegoers? Let's just say they didn't put much effort into thinking it through. Then there were those who went in larger groups, as if strength lay in numbers—I don't know, six or seven of them would watch the same movie and then consult each other to figure out what to write. More than learning, they were interested in hiding. Hiding from what? From other people's judgment, from "what people will say." And who was going to see them if that was what bothered them so much? But anyway, prejudice is deeply ingrained; I think some people have very little personality or a weak character.
There was a girl who commuted from outside the city. I could have understood it, I suppose, if the trip bothered her, because traveling is inconvenient when you live far away, work, and take other classes, etc. This girl complained a bit, but in the end, she did everything quietly. There was another girl who was advised: "If it seems too complicated, watch a documentary." But she ignored the advice and watched a short film instead. She was the first to do so, so she had the chance to present it in class (since the festival lasted a week). As expected, she didn't understand a thing. If I remember correctly, there were two of them who experienced this. They went together and decided to go back again. Well, good for them—"He who buys cheap, buys twice," and "No one can plead their own ignorance." They were warned, didn't listen, and learned the hard way the second time.
Since it was a large class, there was a bit of everything, and there are still three more cases left to analyze. The simplest one is those who went, did the assignment, and moved on—no fuss, just did what they were supposed to do, period.
Another group—which could be called "the least clever among the clever ones"—realized something: one of the movies was already being sold bootlegged or rented at video rental stores. So they took the easy way out, using the simplest logic in the world: "We rent the movie, watch it, and do the assignment—as simple as that—and the professor will never know." Inwardly, I imagine they said to themselves with satisfaction, "Look how smart we are." Of course, the professor would never know unless someone told them. But when I say "the least clever among the clever ones," I mean a case where the person telling the professor was themselves, not a third party. And that’s exactly what happened: they brought it up right in the middle of class. I wonder, "If you planned to act that way, wouldn't it have been better to keep it quiet?" Whatever the case, this group exposed themselves, and their assignments ended up under extra scrutiny due to the possibility they had openly mentioned. Even so, like brave front-line soldiers, some of them went through with the scheme. Even though they passed—thanks to the generosity of the teaching assistant—the head professor commented that it was an inevitable outcome that always happened.
The last case left to mention is my own. I am no smarter than anyone else, so I will add myself to the "least clever among the clever ones" group, with a slight variation. First difference: I kept quiet about it. Second: I searched for the festival's movies online. I actually found them—not all of them, just three. Two of them had very few seeders/download sources, while the third was widely shared. Out of all the screened movies, only three were available online, and the one with plenty of sources was the same one mentioned by the guys I noted earlier. Without knowing about them, but guessing someone would do the same as me, I leaned toward downloading one of the two difficult ones. That’s how I ended up watching the first one that finished downloading. It turned out to be a drama dealing with lesbianism called The Gymnast—a heavy, slow, and completely boring movie with very little worth saving, in my opinion. I submitted the assignment, and it was approved.
The teaching assistant—a young woman... usually, they get assigned something to grade, and with a stern face, they give you an average grade to balance things out based on their perception of the students (this is pure speculation on my part). This TA didn't fail anyone, but she didn't give high grades either. In my experience, it's always better to avoid female TAs. For whatever reason, they always come out with knives out. If possible, it's better to deal directly with the head professor—even if she is a woman, as they tend to be less demanding than female TAs—or failing that, go with a male TA. Again, this isn't very scientific and is based solely on my own limited experience.
The image corresponds to the ticket stub that the cinema actually should have kept. What I did was, once I downloaded the movie, I went to the theater, bought a ticket for the movie I had downloaded, tore it, and stapled the corresponding stub to the assignment I handed in.
Up to this point, it's a nice (or ugly and boring) story, but if I first question the issue of prejudice, why didn't I go? This is where the core issue lies—something no one raised in class, not even me, though it would have been a good excuse (not because it was what went through my mind to justify my behavior, including the risk of being caught, but because another professor brought it up a couple of classes later regarding a different fieldwork assignment).
To analyze this part, we have to look back at what the professors themselves said before the festival and the paper began. On the one hand, they raised the whole issue of prejudice and stigma, and how the affected groups were victims (I'm speaking in general terms here, as the point isn't to elaborate on the topic), which makes you think about the conflict surrounding this social group. On the other hand, we were required to do an assignment using a movie from a film festival—not for the movie itself, but to "experience the environment," to "see how a gay, lesbian, and trans film festival runs," to "see the people who attended," to "interact with the crowd visiting the festival," etc.
This immediately struck me as inappropriate. They had reduced these people to the category of objects. It was no longer about studying the situation where the conflict arose, but about observing these people. It was no longer about going into the middle of the issue (for example, going to the Rose Garden to gather the perspectives of trans women and neighbors—a clear situation of tension); instead, we were faced with going to inspect "the environment." I wondered if we were supposed to sniff around to see if there were expensive perfumes or body odor, or if we were going to see if some abnormal creature with three heads and eight legs would show up. Something didn't add up; the movie was pushed to the background, placing "the environment" front and center.
I think the professors put themselves in a tricky spot, because by studying prejudice, they almost fell into it themselves—despite trying to convey something that, admittedly, is difficult for students to encounter on their own in daily life. Regardless, I don't rule out that the professors had a valid justification.
Luckily for me—and unluckily for others—it turned out to be a somewhat different festival, with few attendees and a few drawbacks, like a lack of organization for some movies. Some films were even difficult to analyze because of their limited scope, to which the solution came from the TA, who said, "All we need now is to make it up"—the only problem being she said it after the papers had already been turned in.
In conclusion: if it was about analyzing a movie, it was better to pick a good, useful one and focus on that. If it was about seeing the studied topic in practice, students should have been sent to the site of the conflict—even with the risk that a student might get hurt, which can always happen. But getting to know "the environment" at a film festival felt rather strange.
(originally posted on 10/24/2007)
No hay comentarios.:
Publicar un comentario