Some Thoughts on the Film Bowling for Columbine, Argentina, and Latin America
With the documentary Bowling for Columbine (2002), I believe its director, Michael Moore, leaves an open question for American society: What is happening that our crime rates are so high?
I do not think Moore reaches the conclusion that American society is, by its very nature, a violent society. However, he does suggest that violence is a characteristic of Americans that has a considerable influence on those high crime rates.
Americans have an amendment to their Constitution that grants them the right to keep and bear arms. Among the civil rights provisions, the Second Amendment to the Constitution states: A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.
I think Americans assimilate this as another value within their society. They see it as something acceptable and do not consider it to be the cause of the problem Moore denounces in the film. When he provides a brief overview of his country's history, it seems that American society views firearms as a means of self-defense, a way to protect itself. But protect itself from what? There is always an enemy against which people must protect themselves, and the first enemy is fear: fear created by governments, politicians, the media, businesses, and so on. That fear is then justified by pointing to society's most vulnerable groups, for example, Black people, a community that has suffered from racism up to the present day.
However, I think there is another issue here. On the one hand, there is the constitutional amendment. The Constitution is the foundation that contains the fundamental principles of a nation, any nation. Therefore, the fact that the right to keep and bear arms is enshrined in the Constitution, even if regulated, carries considerable weight in itself. Looking at this from the perspective of societies that do not regard owning a firearm as something natural may make it difficult to understand. But for Americans, because this right is so deeply ingrained in their way of thinking, it has become just another social value. It may be difficult for them to understand that one of the causes of crime could be easy access to firearms, and that it is considered normal for everyone to be armed with all kinds of weapons.
The film is interesting because it sounds an alarm bell about this issue. However, Moore does not provide precise data that would allow us to analyze the subject. Which segment of the population commits the highest percentage of crimes? The people featured in the film did not belong to society's most marginalized sectors or to the lowest-income and poorest groups. I am not saying that poverty is directly related to crime, but rather that economic imbalances between different social groups may play a role. (1)
Following the text "Argentina in the Latin American Context," I came to the conclusion that there is a very close relationship between crime and those social groups whose institutions have been completely dismantled (clubs, family, school, work, etc.). These people are left adrift. They have no goal around which to organize their lives, and they end up turning to crime.
There is an age group ranging from 17 to 27 in which this process is particularly relevant. It is precisely during this period, in my view, that people establish a direction for their future: they begin working, start families, begin or finish their studies, and so on. If people have no such goals, no direction, and no support system, and if that support is supposed to be provided by the institutions I mentioned earlier (clubs, family, school, work, etc.), then I believe there is a high probability that they will end up engaging in crime, precisely because they are left unprotected.
This is what I was getting at when I mentioned poverty. Not poverty in general, because poverty has always existed, but poverty that reaches extreme levels. I believe these extremes are what the text refers to when it speaks of a "sudden economic imbalance between one social stratum or group and another."
I think the worst consequence occurs when the family breaks down, because the family is the core of society. It is very difficult to find an institution capable of replacing the family. People whose families have disintegrated are left to fend for themselves, with no one to look after them. Without that fundamental support, it is easy for them to end up involved in crime.
But the problem does not affect only the individual. When the family, the core of society, breaks down, society itself is affected. That is why it becomes a social problem that harms every social stratum.
Now, relating these ideas to the film, we see that at the beginning, when Moore speaks with four or five people who are practicing shooting, they appear to be middle-class individuals. Among their occupations are a driver, an employee, and a real estate agent, among others. One of them tells Moore: "We have guns to protect ourselves, to protect our families. If you don't do it, who will? The government? No." This is why I began by suggesting that American society regards owning and carrying firearms as a value in itself. Perhaps people have difficulty considering alternative solutions.
Returning to the question of social support and the family, when Moore crosses into Canada, he shows what is described as a "poor neighborhood" and is surprised by what he sees. I had the same reaction. However, I think the film approaches the problem by focusing precisely on its underlying causes, attempting to prevent people from being left unprotected. This is where the institution known as "social security" comes in. The words themselves say it all: security. It protects people against the consequences of what economic policies may neglect, consequences that can later develop into a much larger problem.
Throughout the film, the director illustrates various social consequences. For example, he shows the town of Flint, devastated by unemployment; Moore's surprise at seeing the Canadian "poor neighborhood"; and other scenes that reveal the influence of social inequality.
Moore talks extensively about fear, the fear generated by the media and those in power. At one point, he says that Americans are "easily frightened." But I believe that the media alone cannot explain why people are so easily frightened. Something must also be felt within society itself, and I suspect that this feeling is reflected in the high crime rates.
The film is based on incidents of violence in schools and later recounts the case of a little girl who was murdered. It is true that the United States has experienced several serious incidents of school violence, at least according to what has reached us through the media. I assume that these events prompted the concern that led to the making of the film.
However, the film never explains where the high figures for firearm-related deaths actually come from, which would be necessary to analyze whether there is a relationship between marginalization and crime.
Nevertheless, the film offers some clues that could serve as indicators. One example is when Moore asks American children whether they believe a system of "social security like Canada's" is necessary. This leads me to suppose that, in the absence of such a system, many people are left outside its coverage. Those who are most likely to be excluded are often those who lack the means to seek alternatives.
One aspect of the film that I found partly misleading was the comparison between Canada's 165 firearm-related deaths per year and the United States' total of 11,127. My point is that Moore does not specify which parameters he uses or whether these are absolute figures.
Canada had a population of approximately 30 million, whereas the United States had around 200 million.
Even so, the American figure is extremely high. Among all the other developed countries mentioned in the film, Germany had the highest number of firearm-related deaths, with 365 cases and a population of approximately 80 million.
I remember that in the early 1990s Germany experienced numerous incidents of violence against foreigners and many attacks on churches. However, this was a problem that the country managed to resolve.
We should also bear in mind that the countries mentioned in the film—Germany, Japan, Canada, the United Kingdom, and others—do not have the high levels of poverty we know in Argentina. By poverty, I mean social inequality and inequity: some people having so much while others have nothing. Nor do they experience the same degree of marginalization that we know here. They also have the social support provided by the system of "social security" that Moore discusses in relation to Canada.
Regarding the text cited earlier, I do not believe that these social inequalities were caused by neoliberalism and the process of globalization established in the 1990s. In fact, the process began several years earlier, but it intensified, and its most significant effects were felt during that decade.
Poverty has always existed, and it does not seem to me—although I have no reliable data to support this claim—that crime has increased at an alarming rate. However, poverty under the welfare state differs from the poverty that existed before it, during the liberal era. Although poverty in the earlier period was worse, the country's circumstances favored that situation.
Under the welfare state, the government intervened, providing a form of social support. As a result, a family living in poverty could obtain the minimum resources it needed without breaking apart.
By contrast, during the process that unfolded over the last decade, the government withdrew from society. An absent state contributed to the breakdown of families. I believe this is the main reason for the severe social inequality that fractured society.
Globalization affected every country in the world. Yet the developed nations largely confronted it through social-democratic systems. In those cases, the state did not completely abandon society but continued to provide the necessary support. I believe this is where we can see the difference between the number of firearm-related victims shown in the film and the figures presented in the charts in the text about Argentina.
What I have just said is a broad and imprecise reflection, but it is what I think after reading the texts and watching the film, together with what one learns through other sources. Above all, it is a general perception of the problem.
The case of the United States is somewhat more complicated because I do believe that the country has abandoned certain sectors of its society. In addition, it has a particularly strong legal and social framework surrounding the issue of firearms. However, the effects of state neglect among vulnerable sectors of American society may be mitigated more quickly—for example, in terms of crime—because of the country's considerable economic resources.
As for the statistics, Latin America ranks second after Africa in the number of violent deaths, with an average of 19 deaths per 100,000 inhabitants (2), compared with an average of 9 violent deaths per 100,000 inhabitants in the rest of the world. Both continents share the distinction of having the greatest social inequalities in the world.
There were not many figures that particularly caught my attention, except for deaths classified as involuntary manslaughter. This is a personal observation: I was aware of the number of deaths caused by traffic accidents, but not of the other cases. In fact, the figures seemed surprisingly low to me in comparison with what I hear about through the media.
Traffic accidents are a separate issue. They are the leading cause of preventable death in the country, and the solution can be summed up in one word: prevention.
I no longer think this is primarily a matter of crime, but rather a social issue. Because these deaths do not receive the same public attention and are not as visible in the media, I believe society is indifferent to them.
In 2004, there were 20 deaths per day, and in 2006, there were 21 deaths per day. Although these cases fall under the legal category of involuntary offenses, I believe their underlying causes are unrelated to criminality.
One thing that caught my attention in the chart entitled "Evolution of Intentional Homicide Rates: Nationwide (1990–2002)" was the presence of several peaks. The text does not explain what caused them. Between 1990 and 2002, there were three peaks: one in 1992, another in 1997, and a third in 2002.
I believe the last one was caused by the crisis Argentina experienced beginning in 2001. There is a gradual upward trend, but I cannot explain the other two peaks. I do not remember any events that might be associated with them.
If they were related to natural disasters and those disasters were in turn associated with violent incidents, possible examples would be the cholera epidemic in 1992 and the major floods in 1997. However, I believe natural disasters are more likely to encourage property crimes, whereas these peaks concern intentional homicides.
In economic terms, by 1992 the country had already left hyperinflation behind and was experiencing economic growth for several years. By 1996, however, it had entered a recession and begun to contract, although the most significant effects of that recession were not felt until approximately 2000, leading into the crisis that began in 2001 and continued afterward.
These two unexplained peaks in the chart particularly caught my attention.
Looking at the other statistics in absolute terms, since the rates differ in some cases, I noticed that the same provinces tend to appear repeatedly. I could not understand why the figures expressed as rates per 100,000 inhabitants differed in some cases. In absolute numbers, however, the provinces that appear are the same ones that have the largest populations. I believe this is a pattern throughout Latin America.
Argentina's prison population stands at around 160 inmates per 100,000 inhabitants. This is high compared with Venezuela's 60, but low compared with the more than 600 in the United States. Internationally, however, among developed countries, Argentina's figure is relatively low.
As the texts point out, criminalization is highly selective. I am not sure whether this is equally true internationally; I suspect it is not. But perhaps criminalization is less selective in developed countries because they do not have the same levels of social inequality found in Latin America.
To conclude, I believe Argentina is in a relatively favorable position compared with the rest of Latin America, despite its social inequalities. Its levels of violence are lower, and I think this is primarily because the country is relatively sparsely populated—especially when compared with Mexico, Brazil, and the countries of Central America—and because it has considerable territorial wealth.
We have not yet experienced the kind of gang violence seen in some Central American countries, the persistent guerrilla violence found in Colombia, motorcycle assassins such as those operating in Paraguay and Brazil, kidnappings such as those occurring in Mexico and Colombia, or the large-scale criminal activity associated with drug trafficking in Mexico and Brazil.
This is what I learn through the media. The same text (3) states explicitly: "Homicides, too, although they have not increased to the same extent—and this is the difference that still gives us a comparative advantage over other populous countries in the region—show successive upward peaks."
The issue of the media is complicated because they seek out only the news that sells. Some time ago, I believe in the mid-1990s, and even earlier, it was common to see daily reports on television about violent robberies targeting bus drivers.
The installation of fare-collection machines was introduced, and the subject disappeared from the news because these violent robberies against bus drivers came to an end.
After the 2001 crisis, a series of extortion kidnappings began, possibly because money was no longer being kept in banks. These were not organized criminal networks of the kind found in the other countries I mentioned earlier, where three or four gangs might be involved in a single kidnapping.
Within a short time, the few kidnapping gangs operating in the Province of Buenos Aires were dismantled. Nevertheless, the media created a sense of insecurity—was Moore right?—by focusing on these kidnappings, especially when they ended tragically or involved a well-known public figure.
At one point, violent car thefts also became a major subject in the media. The underlying cause, the illegal chop shops, was targeted, and the issue disappeared from the news. Is it making a comeback?
I do not know how to relate the role of the media directly to the crime statistics, because they seem to represent two different realities. I see the media as profit-seeking businesses that exploit the subject of crime to some extent. However, I cannot identify a clear connection with criminology that would allow me to determine how much influence the media actually has on society.
The state could also use the media as channels of communication and education through public campaigns, advertisements, programs, and so on. In that case, the profit motive would remain primarily with private companies. Yet I do not see much interest on the part of the state in pursuing this approach, except in exceptional cases, such as campaigns about traffic accidents.
References
(1) Argentina in the Latin American Context, p. 47.
(2) Television program Oppenheimer Presenta, April 3, 2007.
(3) Argentina in the Latin American Context, p. 57.
Bibliography
• Bowling for Columbine — Michael Moore, 2002.
• http://www.jus.gov.ar/ — Criminal Policy section.
Originally published on June 21, 2007.
No hay comentarios.:
Publicar un comentario