sábado, 29 de noviembre de 2025

Spain’s Inner Demons

Spain’s Inner Demons. 

Constanza Cavallero

Bishop Lope de Barrientos at the Dawn of Modern Demonology (Castile, 15th Century)


I have finished reading Spain’s Inner Demons: Bishop Lope de Barrientos at the Dawn of Modern Demonology (Castile, 15th Century) by historian Constanza Cavallero, and I would like to share my thoughts.

I purchased it drawn by the title and my interest in Spanish history, imagining I would find a light, literary work of popular history with an accessible and engaging narrative tone. Upon reading the back cover, I realized I was entering a far more complex field: demonology and witchcraft in early modern Europe. That was my first surprise: I encountered a dense, academic text designed for a specialized reader. Was it a mistake? No. It was, in fact, an opportunity and an intellectual challenge. This is not a book to read in one sitting over coffee; it is a solid, doctrinal, and deeply detailed treatise.

Cavallero does not remain on the surface. As a curious reader—and a layperson on the subject—I found a text that demands commitment. The author meticulously dissects the treatises written by Bishop Lope de Barrientos in the 15th century. It is not a quick read; I had to go back several pages, take notes, and reread paragraphs to avoid losing the thread.

The work is very well written and completely clear, but it becomes demanding. For those approaching it out of general curiosity, it may feel overwhelming; for those seeking historical, theological, and philosophical depth, it is a formidable book.

Cavallero succeeds in reconstructing a political and religious context where demonology was not merely a matter of superstition, but a tool of power and control.

The author analyzes Barrientos' anti-superstition treatises—written around the mid-15th century—and demonstrates how his thought marked the first steps of Iberian demonology. The interesting part is that, unlike Central Europe, where the fear of the devil resulted in mass persecutions, Castile adopted a more cautious stance. The book explains how Barrientos and his followers limited the inquisitorial aspect of witchcraft: they rejected superstitious practices, yes, but without the extreme violence that characterized Central Europe. Some historians call this "Spanish caution." While a "radical" demonology developed in the rest of Europe (especially in Alpine regions and Central Europe)—viewing witchcraft as a physical reality with tangible pacts, flights, and transmutations, as well described by Johannes Nider in his Formicarius, and later Kramer and Sprenger with the Malleus Maleficarum, which legitimized the ideas of witch flights, physical transmutations, and systematic persecutions—something different was happening in Castile.

Barrientos, far from being the fanatical inquisitor presented in school textbooks or simplistic television portrayals, proposes a rationalist and skeptical approach. His thesis was revolutionary for its time:

•    Most phenomena attributed to the devil actually have natural, physiological, or psychological explanations (such as melancholy).

•    If witchcraft is mostly a deception or an illusion, there is no reason for the pyre.

•    Faced with the "ignorant" person who believes in magic, the response must be confession, instruction, and order, not torture.

From the perspective of an average reader, the book might seem overly theoretical, distant in time, and potentially overwhelming. However, for students of history, religion, philosophy, or politics, it is a work of great value. Even as someone who considers themselves unfamiliar with the subject, I read it completely, aiming to understand it as best as I could. Far from being a flaw, that density is part of its richness.

The final chapter is particularly eye-opening: it shows how demonology contributed to the construction of "other-Christians" and the consolidation of political and religious power in Castile. Barrientos defended a rationalist and skeptical stance: faced with the fanaticism that viewed the devil as the ultimate enemy, he proposed instruction and confession over the stake and torture. In certain periods and contexts, the Spanish Inquisition maintained a far more prudent stance than its European counterparts, largely avoiding the collective hysteria of witch hunts ("a relative absence of excessive outbursts and diabolical constructions of collective crimes extracted under torture," p. 155).

Ultimately, I finished the book with the feeling of having added another valuable piece to my library. It is clear to me that to understand the development of witchcraft in subsequent centuries, one must first understand those who, pen and reason in hand, attempted—and succeeded—in limiting the horror ("those features of original restraint in the Iberian world").

As a final note, which is highlighted on the back cover, the work was awarded the Prize of the XII Inter-School / History Department Conferences in 2009. It is a work recognized within academic circles, highlighting its value as a rigorous research effort within its field.


No hay comentarios.:

Publicar un comentario